Scapholunate Ligament Tear

Home » Sports Injuries » Wrist & Hand » Scapholunate Ligament Tear
Scapholunate Ligament Tear 2017-12-07T23:33:35+00:00

Scapholunate ligament tear

By Asheesh Bedi, M.D.

Although there are many ligaments and injuries in the wrist, a scapholunate ligament tear is the most commonly injured. The scapholunate ligament connects the scaphoid to the lunate. The most important part of the ligament is on the back (dorsal side) of the wrist. Normally, the scaphoid and the lunate move together because the scapholunate ligament connects them tightly. When a scapholunate ligament tear occurs, the scaphoid bends forward (flexes) and the lunate bends backwards (extends) and a gap may form between the bones.

The wrist is a complex joint which is composed of the end of the radius (the big bone in the forearm, on the thumb side), the ulna (the small bone in the forearm, on the small finger side) as well as the carpal bones. There are 8 carpal bones: the scaphoid, lunate, triquetrum, pisiform, hamate, capitate, trapezoid, and trapezium. These bones are all connected by ligaments, making the wrist a very complex joint which is actually a collection of multiple joints.

The scaphoid is a small bone in the wrist on the thumb side. It is located in the thumb side of the wrist. If you put your thumb up in the air (like a hitchhiker) you will make a small depression at the base of your thumb. This depression is called the “anatomic snuffbox.” If you press with your finger deep into the floor of the anatomic snuffbox, you can barely feel the scaphoid. The scaphoid is shaped like a twisted peanut and is only about 1 inch long or a little shorter. 80% of it is covered with cartilage.

The lunate is a small bone in the center of the wrist right next to the scaphoid. It is shaped like a crescent moon when viewed from the side.

Although there are many ligaments and injuries in the wrist, a scapholunate ligament tear is the most commonly injured. The scapholunate ligament connects the scaphoid to the lunate. The most important part of the ligament is on the back (dorsal side) of the wrist. Normally, the scaphoid and the lunate move together because the scapholunate ligament connects them tightly. When a scapholunate ligament tear occurs, the scaphoid bends forward (flexes) and the lunate bends backwards (extends) and a gap may form between the bones.


What is a scapholunate ligament tear in athletes?

A scapholunate ligament tear can vary from mild sprains (partial tears or “stretches”) all the way to complete tears with other torn ligaments. They may also be accompanied by other injuries such as a scaphoid fracture or a lunate dislocation. These are more severe injuries, and for the purpose of this article, we will still stay focused on the scapholunate ligament tear.

scapholunate ligament tear

One way to think about the scapholunate ligament tear is to divide them into four categories in order from mild to severe: predynamic, dynamic, static, and scapholunate advanced collapse.

Predynamic, or occult, injury is the mildest form of the scapholunate ligament tear. It is a partial tear of the ligament. X-rays are normal, but the partial tear may be visualized by an MRI or by looking in the joint with an arthroscope at the time of surgery.

In a dynamic injury, the ligament is completely torn or stretched to the point that it can’t do its job. There may also be some mild injury to other surrounding ligaments. Regular x-rays are normal but stress x-rays show a gap between the scaphoid and the lunate (see next section below “How is a scapholunate ligament tear diagnosed?” for discussion regarding stress x-rays.)

In a static injury, the ligament is completely torn, and some of the surrounding ligaments are also injured. Regular x-rays show a gap between the scaphoid and the lunate.

In a scapholunate advanced collapse (SLAC) injury, the ligament is completely torn, and the injury has been there a long time (years) causing arthritis, or evidence of cartilage damage, to be seen on regular x-rays in addition to the gapping between the scaphoid and the lunate. This is a predictable pattern of arthritis that develops with longstanding, untreated ligament injuries.

Injuries may also be classified according to how long it has been since the injury: Acute (less than 4 weeks), subacute (4 weeks to 6 months), and chronic (more than 6 months).

How is a scapholunate ligament tear diagnosed?

A scapholunate ligament tear is usually caused by a fall or by a sudden load on the wrist. Sometimes the athlete may not recall the fall because they didn’t seek treatment immediately, but instead sought treatment weeks later when they continued to have pain. The athlete may have pain in the center or on the thumb side of the wrist, especially with activities such as push-ups, or other activities that load the wrist. There may also be grip weakness, snapping, swelling, or popping.

When the physician examines the athlete, the scapholunate interval may be tender and swollen. The Watson scaphoid shift test can be helpful. This is done by bending the wrist toward the small finger, and then the physician applies pressure to the palm side of the scaphoid as the wrist is bent toward the thumb. Relief of pressure will allow the scaphoid to slip back into place with a clunk. However, this test may be positive in many normal wrists, so it must be interpreted with caution and compared to the other side.

There are several imaging studies that may be used: standard x-rays, stress x-rays, and MRI.

Standard x-rays rule out other problems such as fractures. If the athlete has a static injury (see “What is a scapholunate tear?” in the above section), the standard x-rays will show gapping between the lunate and scaphoid and increased angulation between the scaphoid and the lunate. If the athlete has a longstanding tear with a SLAC wrist, arthritis may be seen on the x-rays.

If standard x-rays are normal, stress x-rays may be useful to see gapping or instability that is too mild to show up on standard x-rays. To perform stress x-rays, the athlete simple makes a tight fist for one x-ray, then bends the wrist forcefully towards the small finger for another x-ray, then bends the wrist towards the thumb for another. The physician may also order an x-ray during which your fingers are gently pulled on. These x-rays may show gapping or abnormal angulation that only occurs during activities, but not when the wrist is at rest. Sometimes, x-rays of the normal wrist may be taken for comparison.

Depending on the situation, MRI may be useful. This may be ordered as an MRI arthrogram, which means the radiologist will inject dye into the wrist with a needle before the MRI. If there is a tear or a hole in a ligament, the dye will leak through. However, MRI’s and arthrograms are not 100% accurate. Sometimes an MRI may miss an injury because the ligament is so small and sometimes the dye will leak through even if there is not a ligament injury. That is why your physician will take into account your symptoms, history, exam, and x-rays rather than just relying on a MRI alone to come up with the best treatment plan.

If the diagnosis is still unclear, or if it is clear that surgery is needed, arthroscopy (looking inside the wrist with a camera at surgery) may be used to clearly define the injury. Arthroscopy is the most accurate way to define the scapholunate ligament tear, but it is a surgery.

Scapholunate ligament tear treatment

Treatment without surgery may be appropriate in a predynamic injury, or a mild sprain of the scapholunate ligament without changes on x-rays. This may involve a brace or a cast for 2-6 weeks, minimizing activity that causes pain such a tight gripping or pushing, and anti-inflammatory medications such as ibuprofen. Then a removable brace may be used for activities, as gradual strengthening and stretching is added. Return to sports depends on the severity of the symptoms and the type of sport as well as if the athlete can participate in the sport with a cast or brace.

If this is not successful, surgery such as wrist arthroscopy may be considered. Based on what is found at the time of arthroscopy, the ligament may be debrided (“cleaned up”) or pins may be placed with a cast. 

When to See the Doctor

Hundreds of athletes sustain acute injuries everyday, which can be treated safely at home using the P.R.I.C.E. principle. But if there are signs or symptoms of a serious injury, emergency first aid should be provided while keeping the athlete calm and still until emergency service personnel arrive. Signs of an emergency situation when you should seek care and doctor treatment can include:

  • Bone or joint that is clearly deformed or broken
  • Severe swelling and/or pain,
  • Unsteady breathing or pulse
  • Disorientation or confusion
  • Paralysis, tingling, or numbness

In addition, an athlete should seek medical care if acute symptoms do not go away after rest and home treatment using the P.R.I.C.E principle.

Can Telemedicine Help?

Telemedicine is gaining popularity because it can help bring you and the doctor together quicker and more efficiently. It is particularly well suited for sports medicine, facilitating the diagnoses, treatment and prevention of sports related injuries both on and off the field. There are times when It can be very difficult to get an appointment with primary care doctors or specialists and Telemedicine can help to provide very quick treatment options. But if you prefer a more personal or face-to-face relationship, telemedicine might not be the option for you.
600x300 HealthTap

When is treatment with scapholunate ligament tear surgery appropriate for athletes?

If there is gapping and increased angulation between the scaphoid and lunate on x-rays, or if treatment without surgery hasn’t been successful, then surgery is warranted.

If the x-rays don’t show gapping, but treatment with a cast or brace has not been successful, arthroscopy is an option. This involves placing a camera in the wrist to examine the injury. Based on what is found, the joint may be debrided (“cleaned up”). If significant instability is found, pins may be placed to hold the bones in place and/or an incision may be made to repair or reconstruct the ligaments.

If x-rays show gapping, as in dynamic or static injuries, then surgery is warranted. This involves repairing the ligament. The ligament repair may be augmented by tightening up the capsule tissue on the back of the wrist. Then pins are usually placed to help protect the ligament repair while it is healing. After surgery, a splint is placed which is then changed to a cast at 1-2 weeks. The cast protects the repair as well as the pins, which are protruding through the skin. The pins are removed at an office visit 10-12 weeks after surgery. Then range of motion and strengthening exercises are begun.

When can I return to play after surgery?

Return to sport depends on the athlete’s exact injury, surgery, and sport. The athlete should discuss this with their physician. Certainly, leg work and the well arm may be used throughout the recovery process. Return to contact sports may be considered after pin removal with a removable protective brace. Return to contact sports without a brace may be considered at 6 months.

When might surgery fail?

If x-rays show gapping and arthritis, then ligament repair is not likely to work. In that case, treatment without surgery may be tried because surgical options are more involved and may involve removing some wrist bones or causing some bone to grow together (fusion). In this situation, treatment without surgery may involve bracing, anti-inflammatory medications, avoiding painful activities, and cortisone injections.

References:

  • Kuo CE, Wolfe SW. Scapholunate instability: current concepts in diagnosis and management. J Hand Surg 2008;33A:998-1013.
  • Lewis DM, Osterman AL. Scapholunate instability in athletes. Clin Sports Med 2001;20(1):131-40.
  • Manuel J, Moran SL. The diagnosis and treatment of scapholunate instability. Orthop Clin N Am 2007;38:261-77.
  • Walsh JJ, Berger RA, Cooney WP. Current status of scapholunate interosseous ligament injuries. J Am Acad Orthop Surg 2002;10:32-42
  • Tina Quirk

    When should we consider removing bones??

    • Duncan Smith

      Generally once the injury is bad enough you could consider “removing” bones. You should, of course, attempt more conservative measures first such as activity modification, rest, bracing and mild pain medications. If that fails, more invasive treatments can be discussed with your surgeon. Options range from trying to repair the soft tissue if the injury happened recently (is acute) all the way to excision of bones and fusion of bones – or both!

      Treatment is dependent on your goals. Fusions of the bones in your wrist limit range of motion but are successful in removing pain related to wear and tear (arthritis). Other procedures that remove some of the bones in the wrist (proximal row carpectomy) can keep some motion but may have some weakness. Studies show both avenues do well in the right patient.

  • Justin Taylor

    Any thoughts or experiences on the Burnelli procedure for this? I have a surgeon that thinks it is the best for my wrist I’m a little hesitant but I cant have it feel like this forever.

    • HL

      I had SL repair, modified Brunelli procedure, capsulodesis Dec. 26, 2016. Pins removed March 13, 2017. Occupational therapy 3x/wk for past 3 1/2 months, with more months required. (Check with insurance- mine only pays 20 visits per year unless Dr. can justify need and insurance board approves more.) Dr. had me off work for 2 months after SL repair, plus another 2 weeks after pin removal. Very painful procedure and rehab. I am now 5 weeks post-op from pin removal. Pain is worse than pre-surgery. Very limited range of motion now. Spending 3-5 hours every day doing therapy (OT has me doing exercises 8 x/day on my own, plus 1 1/2 hours at OT 3x/wk). Two Occupational therapists say expect very little improvement, two say I’ll probably gain a little more range of motion, but will be lucky if I hit 50%. They all say it takes a year to rehab from this surgery. Dr. told me post-surgery that they expect an average of 50% range of motion after this surgery. I recommend careful evaluation and information gathering before you decide to proceed. I lived with greater than 50% tear for 9 years before surgery. I had pain, but also had almost full ROM, so could do any activity I wanted as long as I was willing to bear the accompanying pain. Now I am unable to do many things due to very limited ROM. Had I known they expect 50% average ROM, I would have continued to live with torn ligament and not had the procedure done, as ROM was far more important to me than pain. They tell me the pain will decrease over the next year, and that people generally aren’t happy they had the procedure done until a year post-surgery. I’m only 4 months into this. I recommend finding people 1 year, and also 5 years out and see what their experience has been.

    • Brad

      I had the SL survey as well. Over 1 yr post Op and not happy at all with results. Wrist still very painful and weak and ROM sux. I wish I would have not done surgery…at least this one.

  • Justin Taylor

    Thanks for the info…the wrist brace i wear is not looking so bad now.

45 Shares
Share45
Tweet
+1
Pin
Share